FinCEN's BOI Reporting Reversal: What the Domestic Company Exemption Means for Foreign Entities

The Regulatory Whiplash That Changed Everything

If your compliance team has felt dizzy tracking beneficial ownership reporting requirements over the past year, you're not alone. What began as the most comprehensive ownership transparency mandate in U.S. history has transformed into one of the most dramatic regulatory reversals in recent memory.

On March 21, 2025, the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) issued an interim final rule that fundamentally redefined the Corporate Transparency Act's reporting requirements. The headline: all U.S. domestic companies are now exempt from beneficial ownership information (BOI) reporting. If your company was formed in the United States, you're off the hook—regardless of who owns it.

But here's what most businesses missed in the relief of exemption: foreign entities registered to do business in the United States still have reporting obligations. And those obligations come with compressed deadlines, unclear guidance, and significant penalties for non-compliance.

The shift represents more than regulatory relief for domestic companies. It signals a fundamental recalibration of anti-money laundering priorities, creates a two-tiered transparency regime, and leaves foreign-owned businesses navigating uncertainty while their domestic competitors celebrate exemption.

Understanding the Corporate Transparency Act's Tumultuous Journey

The Corporate Transparency Act passed in 2021 with bipartisan support, designed to combat money laundering, terrorist financing, and financial crime by requiring companies to disclose their beneficial owners to FinCEN. The goal: eliminate anonymous shell companies that criminals use to hide illicit proceeds.

Initial regulations, finalized in September 2022, established comprehensive reporting requirements. Companies created or registered before January 1, 2024 faced a January 1, 2025 deadline. Those formed in 2024 had 90 days to report. Companies created after January 1, 2025 received just 30 days to file.

The compliance burden was substantial: Every reporting company needed to identify beneficial owners (individuals owning 25% or more or exercising substantial control), collect personal information including addresses and identification documents, and file detailed reports through FinCEN's electronic system. Penalties for non-compliance included civil fines up to $500 per day and criminal penalties of up to two years imprisonment.

Then came the legal challenges. Multiple federal district courts issued preliminary injunctions, questioning FinCEN's statutory authority under the Corporate Transparency Act. In December 2024, a Texas district court issued a nationwide injunction halting enforcement. A subsequent ruling in January 2025 stayed implementation pending appeal.

When the Trump administration assumed office in January 2025, policy priorities shifted dramatically. On March 2, 2025, the Department of Treasury announced its intent to exempt U.S. companies and U.S. persons from BOI reporting requirements, focusing enforcement on foreign entities presenting the highest money laundering and national security risks.

Three weeks later, FinCEN delivered on that promise.

The March 2025 Interim Final Rule: Who Reports Now

The interim final rule, published March 26, 2025, rewrites the definition of "reporting company" to mean only foreign entities registered to do business in the United States. Specifically:

Exempt from BOI Reporting (No Action Required):

• All companies created or formed under U.S. state law

• All U.S. territories and tribal jurisdiction entities

• All U.S. persons who are beneficial owners of any company

• Previously filed reports for domestic companies (no correction or update needed)

Still Required to Report:

• Foreign entities formed under foreign country law that have registered to do business in any U.S. state or tribal jurisdiction by filing with a secretary of state or similar office

• These foreign reporting companies face April 25, 2025 deadline (for entities registered before March 26, 2025)

• Foreign entities registered on or after March 26, 2025 have 30 days from registration effective date

Critical Detail Often Overlooked: Foreign reporting companies do not need to report U.S. persons as beneficial owners. This means if a foreign entity has both foreign and U.S. beneficial owners, only the foreign individuals require disclosure.

What This Means for Different Business Structures

The rule's impact varies significantly based on how your business is structured:

U.S. Companies with Foreign Ownership

A Delaware LLC wholly owned by foreign individuals or entities is exempt from BOI reporting. The company's domestic formation status controls, not its ownership structure. This represents perhaps the most significant shift—eliminating transparency requirements for the exact structures that raised the most money laundering concerns.

Foreign Companies Doing Business in the U.S.

A German GmbH registered to conduct business in California must file BOI reports by April 25, 2025, disclosing its foreign beneficial owners (but not any U.S. persons with ownership interests). This entity faces full reporting obligations with compressed timeframes.

Joint Ventures and Partnership Structures

A U.S. limited partnership with foreign limited partners is exempt because it's a domestic entity. However, if that partnership owns a foreign subsidiary that registers to do business in the United States, the subsidiary must report.

Holding Company Structures

U.S. holding companies with foreign operating subsidiaries are exempt from BOI reporting. The foreign subsidiaries also avoid reporting unless they directly register to conduct business in a U.S. state (rare for true foreign operating companies).

Compliance Obligations for Foreign Reporting Companies

If your entity falls within the remaining reporting requirements, here's what you must disclose:

Company Information:

• Legal name and any trade names or DBAs

• Current U.S. address (principal place of business)

• State or tribal jurisdiction of registration

• IRS Taxpayer Identification Number

Beneficial Owner Information (for each foreign beneficial owner):

• Full legal name

• Date of birth

• Residential address

• Unique identifying number from acceptable identification document (passport, driver's license, or foreign identification)

• Image of the identification document

Company Applicant Information (for foreign entities registered after January 1, 2024):

• Individual who directly filed registration documents

• Individual primarily responsible for directing or controlling the filing (if different)

Reports file electronically through FinCEN's BOI E-Filing system at https://boiefiling.fincen.gov. There is no filing fee.

Strategic Implications: Why This Matters Beyond Compliance

The domestic company exemption creates significant competitive and strategic considerations:

Anti-Money Laundering Effectiveness Questioned

Critics, including members of Congress, argue that exempting all domestic companies—including those with 100% foreign ownership—undermines the Corporate Transparency Act's anti-money laundering purpose. Illicit actors can simply form U.S. entities rather than operating through foreign companies registered domestically.

The narrow focus on foreign-registered entities may catch legitimate international businesses while missing domestic structures used for illicit purposes. This represents a policy choice prioritizing reduced regulatory burden over comprehensive transparency.

Foreign Direct Investment Implications

Foreign companies now face transparency requirements their U.S. competitors avoid. A Japanese manufacturer considering U.S. expansion must choose between:

1. Operating through U.S. subsidiary: Creates a domestic entity (no BOI reporting) but may complicate repatriation of profits and creates additional regulatory complexity

2. Direct registration: Maintains simpler corporate structure but triggers BOI reporting obligations with ongoing update requirements

This disparity may influence foreign direct investment structuring decisions, though tax and liability considerations typically carry more weight.

Ongoing Uncertainty and Risk

FinCEN is accepting comments on the interim final rule and intends to finalize regulations during 2025. The final rule could:

• Reimpose requirements on U.S. companies with foreign ownership

• Expand exemptions to cover all entities regardless of formation jurisdiction

• Establish different requirements for different risk profiles

Foreign reporting companies facing April 2025 deadlines operate in regulatory uncertainty. Investing resources in compliance today may prove unnecessary if final rules broaden exemptions. Waiting risks penalties if current requirements remain.

Litigation Exposure Continues

Legal challenges to the Corporate Transparency Act continue in the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals. Courts could uphold the rule, strike it down entirely, or remand to FinCEN for further refinement. The SEC took the unusual step in July 2025 of asking courts to rule on statutory authority questions, suggesting current leadership wants judicial clarity rather than administrative resolution.

Practical Guidance for Foreign Entities

If your entity meets the foreign reporting company definition, take these actions now:

1. Confirm Registration Status

Determine whether your entity has registered to do business in any U.S. state or tribal jurisdiction by filing with a secretary of state or similar office. Simple qualification to do business triggers reporting obligations; mere business activity without formal registration does not.

2. Identify Beneficial Owners

Document all individuals who:

• Own or control 25% or more of ownership interests

• Exercise substantial control over the entity through senior officer positions, authority over appointments, or other control mechanisms

Remember: U.S. persons need not be reported even if they meet beneficial ownership criteria.

3. Collect Required Documentation

Gather identification documents, addresses, and personal information for all beneficial owners identified. Ensure you have current, valid identification with images suitable for electronic filing.

4. File by Deadline

Entities registered before March 26, 2025: April 25, 2025 deadline Entities registered on or after March 26, 2025: 30 days from registration effective date

5. Establish Update Procedures

Any change to previously reported information requires an updated BOI report within 30 days. Changes triggering updates include:

• Changes in beneficial ownership (acquisitions, sales, transfers)

• Changes in beneficial owner information (addresses, legal names)

• Changes in company information (name, address, jurisdiction)

6. Document Compliance Decisions

Maintain contemporaneous documentation of your determination regarding reporting obligations, beneficial owner identification, and filing decisions. If FinCEN or law enforcement later questions your compliance, this documentation supports your good-faith efforts.

Looking Ahead: What to Expect in 2025

The interim final rule represents a pause, not a conclusion. Here's what businesses should monitor:

Final Rule Publication: FinCEN committed to finalizing regulations during 2025 after reviewing public comments. The final rule could substantively change current requirements based on feedback regarding anti-money laundering effectiveness, administrative burden, and policy objectives.

Judicial Decisions: The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals will rule on the Corporate Transparency Act's statutory authority. An adverse ruling could eliminate BOI reporting requirements entirely or significantly narrow FinCEN's regulatory scope.

Congressional Action: Members of Congress have expressed concern about the domestic company exemption undermining money laundering prevention. Legislation could reimpose requirements or further refine the regulatory framework.

Enforcement Approach: FinCEN has not yet issued detailed guidance on how it will enforce requirements against foreign reporting companies. Penalties, audit procedures, and compliance verification processes remain unclear.

The Bottom Line

For most U.S. businesses, the March 2025 interim rule brings welcome relief from burdensome reporting requirements. The exemption of domestic companies eliminates compliance obligations for millions of entities.

For foreign companies registered in the United States, the landscape became more complex, not simpler. You face reporting deadlines while operating in regulatory uncertainty, with unclear enforcement mechanisms and potential rule changes ahead.

The key: don't ignore obligations because the rules might change. Foreign reporting companies must evaluate current requirements, make informed compliance decisions, and document their reasoning. The penalty for non-compliance—up to $500 daily plus potential criminal liability—far exceeds the cost of filing a BOI report.

FinCEN's dramatic reversal signals broader regulatory philosophy shifts under the current administration. But philosophy changes don't eliminate legal obligations. Until final rules clarify the landscape or courts invalidate requirements entirely, foreign reporting companies must navigate the compliance framework that exists today—uncertain though it may be.

About the Author

Suresh Iyer turns financial uncertainty into strategic clarity. With 25 years spanning Big Four audit leadership, corporate finance, and fractional CFO work, he guides publicly traded companies and high-growth startups through IPOs, complex transactions, and transformational growth—bringing technical precision and forward-thinking strategy to organizations that refuse to settle for reactive reporting.

JHS USA provides comprehensive compliance advisory and business risk services to companies navigating complex regulatory requirements. Our team monitors regulatory developments, interprets practical implications, and helps clients implement efficient compliance frameworks. Contact us to discuss your beneficial ownership reporting obligations and broader compliance strategy.

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, regulatory, or compliance advice. Companies should consult with qualified advisors regarding their specific reporting obligations.

Copyright © 2025 JHS USA. All rights reserved.